Monday, April 24, 2006

I've been neither funny nor clever in recent days, and as much as I'd like to post my shopping list and a copy of my insurance policy, I thought I'd post something of real content.

This is a blog entry from someone who I don't know who that someone is. Another someone sent it to me, and I thought it was both brilliant and sort of stupid at times. I thought the collective you might like it.


------

When you build up a structure and slap the word church on a sign out front, it becomes very easy for people to forget that church is not a place to go once a week, but rather something that we are.  Uh oh, here I go...
Forgive me, but I dont need a weekly program of rehearsed hooky tunes followed by a barrage of announcements and a puffy theological dissertation.  I dont need cell groups, home groups, singles groups, young married groups or mens groups.  Frankly, I'm pretty grouped out.  What I need is fellowship.  Not "Fellowship Bible" or "Fellowship Community" or "Fellowship Covenant" or "Fellowship Baptist."  I need community.  Not "Christ Community" or "Faith Community" or "Real Life Community."  And dont get me started on grace.  God knows we need that, but not in the form of another catchy church name.  I don't need to read another trite quip on a marquis telling me that a church is "prayer conditioned" or that "regular bible check ups prevent truth decay."    And I don't need to be professionally greeted at the door of the sanctuary.  I need to be known, not counted and alphabetized.  After all, Mr. Greeter, is it really nice to see me, or are you just happy to see another seat filled?  No, I don't want a bulletin.  Associate Pastor Whats-His-Name is going to read it all to me during the prayer-slash-announcement time anyway.  Besides, it's a good way for him to squeeze in some face time between "worship" and the offering.  Oh excuse me, I mean "tithe"  (the word church leadership uses to ensure Gods promises will be fulfilled to His people).  The "freedom isn't free" sales pitch:  Freedom comes at a cost!  And that cost is 10 percent of everything you have.  But if you're a guest, please don't feel obligated to give (only members should feel obligated).  Excuse me, do you not see that we are clinging so desperately to these laws that Jesus [admittedly] lived to fulfill, but also bled and died to free us from?  James says if you take on one law you must carry the weight of the entire law on your shoulders.  Brothers and sisters, that is not a burden we were meant to carry in light of the finishing work of Christ!  Tithe is merely a control device for leaders who can't trust the work of the Holy Spirit in the Body if Christ (or who don't understand that we have been freed from those regulations and rules).  It's the same thing they did back in the early church with circumcision.  Am I saying we shouldn't give?  By no means!  The apostle Paul has plenty to say about that.  He said that we should excel in the grace of giving just as we excel in the other good gifts (he also had a teensy weensy tiny bit to say about the end of the law too, which includes the mandate of tithing).  I didn't want to get started on tithe.  Guess its too late for that.  This is not merely a piece on tithing.  Rather, it is a satirical challenge issued to the prodigal church of America.
You see, we don't need churches with schedules to keep, fundraisers to promote, and people to reintroduce to life under law.  No thanks.  I'm over that.  What I need is a safe place for people who know each other intimately and, at a moments notice, can lay hands on one other and exercise their gifts with confidence and without fear.  Gifts like prophecy and healing.  It isn't wrong for me to desire a place where I can come to be prayed over without the formality of a scheduled altar call at the end of a service.  Besides, what kind of service is it to erect a building and obligate everyone to come and help pay the utility bills, outrageous mortgages, expansion funds, and salaries (for a staff who claims to equip, but mostly enables laziness amongst the members by doing all the work for them) when there are congregants who can't find healing from a common cold, let alone afford to pay their own rent?  And when we do attempt to reach out to those people, we stamp our church brand all over the project and piously advertise our "mission."
Is that authenticity?  Yes, it is very authentic.  But I can take you out in my back yard and show you something very authentic that my dog left behind - and no amount of clever marketing will make it stink any less.  We don't need authenticity.  We need truth.  And truth is not a marketing strategy.  It is not programmed.  Truth is only a formula when it is math.  The gospel is not math.  It is not an equation.  It is mystery - mystery revealed in the person of Christ our Deliverer, who never prepared a four point sermon, rented out a billboard, or handed out a tract.  He taught, he corrected, he rebuked, he interacted, he had compassion, he healed, he prayed, he studied, he believed in others, he cared for the poor, he had close friends who knew him well, and he looked people in the eyes simply because he took the time to.  But most of all, he loved.  And that's the truth.

-----

What do you think?

Peace,
Justin

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

whoever that person is, I think most people want that same thing. I know I do, if that church is out there, I want to go. Not just words, but actions with it.

RA Cook said...

Protest is fine, alternatives are better.
This seems like the kind of thing that gets guys like me who pretty much agree with all of it to nod our heads--"Yeah, screw lame names! Screw church as marketing campaign! Screw inward focus!" but won't really DO anything.
If this guy comes back and says--"And here's how we create my alternative vision" there will be a Ryan shaped hole in the wall of my office to go help.

Keith W said...

House church man, that is the way to get it done (and that is where the "church" culture seems to be going from a trends perspective;... the big building thing won't last because ... well, read the blog... and that is coming from George Barna, the guy who predicted 30 years ago that the MEGA church's are comming).

My biggest frustration(s) that the blog kinda hit but glanced over is that the Americal Organized Church is 1)reaching mainly the middle class with a pathetically cheep Gospel (come to christ, help make the coffee (serve) on Sundays, don't change a thing about how you live except don't swear as much, go to heaven) .... 2)ignores the poor EXCEPT for feel good crap (like 1 week missions trips that cost $1k per person to fly somewhere and don't really do squat for the locals long-term or a local "outreach" where we spend more on the pizza for fellowship afterwards than we do on helping others. The church is missing Matthew 25 and the consequences are stagering according to scripture.

So I say house Church. I will be planting one in 5 years... ok I just made that up,... but why not. All the "tithes" go to the poor; no building, no staff.

Crap, that means I will have to leave this MEGA church that pays my bills and get a corporate job again though....

Keith

Justin said...

OK, I didn't want to add my comments for fear of skewing the discussion...but I think I'm giving myself way too much credit there. So, here are my thoughts...

...I'm with both Ryan and Keith a bit, and with myself even more.

I think the author of this piece offers some good thoughts about what's wrong with the church. I think his words on the "let's build a church and rely on the people who attend to fund our debt," and "let's spend 2 hours in the ghetto or a week on the mission trip so we feel better about being better off than we probably should be" are well-written and right on. However...I'm with Ryan...pointing out the problem is the part for simple people and movie critics. It's what I do best, and fixing the problem is what I do much more worserest. I'm excellent (and quite proud of myself) at sitting around and bitching, and very bad about offering proactive, positive suggestions to make things better.

It's the difference between saying, "Cincinnati City Council has dropped the ball time after time on healing race relations in our city, fixing our violent crime problem in Over the Rhine, and bringing business back to downtown" and saying "Cincinnati City Council should establish a regular meeting of black city leaders and white city leaders to have an honest dialogue about race relations, police protection in over-the-rhine should be doubled with two-partner teams patrolling 24/7, and tax incentives should be offered to retailers and restaurants who are willing to commit to a 3-year lease in a downtown space." (These may not be good ideas, but at least they're ideas...we all know Cincinnati is in poor shape and that the council is at least partly responsible...but what do you do about it?)

I'm tired of churches called "community" and "grace," but I also tend to be surrounded by both, and don't need those words to shine out to me in a dark place. I'm wary of smiling greeters opening doors for me with the same rote-sounding "good morning, welcome to insert church name here!"...but I've never been the person with no sense of mission or purpose whose first act of outward focus is opening the door for churchgoers, and I'm not the recluse who looks forward to the one morning a week when somebody smiles at him. I may be tired of churches confusing fundraising and worship-by-tithing, but if I'm being honest with myself, it wasn't that long ago that I first let a check go into the purple velvet bag for the first time, and felt the freedom of trusting in provision more than fearing scarcity.

I think you have to go through the cynical phase...good lord, I'm still in the middle of it...but at some point you stop just pointing out what's wrong and start to think about what might be better.

That's all.

Peace,
Justin

The Gooch said...

Funny this church topic comes up in every group of christians that I know. I've noticed that more and more people expect leaders, especially church leaders, to do the things that they won't do or don't want to do. I understand frustration in church leadership and frustration about what's going on, but if we really believe in church and that we are part of the church, we are part of the problem. I'm as guilty as anyone of passing the buck and pointing at someone else and say "I act this way because he acts that way." The bottom line to this whole church thing is that it's never going to get better when every "Christian" that gets frustrated with their church decides to leave. It's what I call the "Fat Bastard Cycle", from Austin Powers "I eat because I'm not happy, I'm not happy because I eat." If people would just suck it up, be frustrated, proactive, and stop being big babies that take their ball and go home, churches would work. How great would it be for someone, or a group of people to be able to say "I was frustrated with the church, too, but I worked through it. I know what you're going through, here's what I did." The answer isn't in home churches, it's not in a building, it's not in OTR. Nobody can say that because it's easier to just walk away. Maybe I'm just gullible, but I think that would make a huge difference. "Mega churches" are getting some things right and some things wrong, but people have conflicting expectations. We want to be leaders in the church but we want the church to take care of us. A church isn't the staff, pastors, board, elders, or anything like that. It's the people. Until that is fully accepted and understood, nothing will ever change. People are going to keep walking away because it's easier, and then we have someone to blame other than ourselves.

I don't know most of you, so I feel like I need to leave a disclaimer, but I won't. I just hope this doesn't offend anyone.

Anonymous said...

Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! As a church planter and a quickly growing body of believers, I personally agree and struggle with everything that all of you shared. Thank you for your candidness and honesty.

This is my first official blog entry of any kind so please bear with my rambling. I don't really even like to write.

I can honestly say (most people who come to the church that I pastor argue with me about this admittedly) that I personally don't care if anyone shows up on Sunday. Yes, I said it. So now that its out there let me tell you why.

The Sunday gathering is an event sponsored by the church, just like a lot of large, intermediate, and cell level events put on by the church. All in the hopes of moving people toward a life transformation (note that this doesn't mean life will get rosey and peachy...in most cases, it means life will get more difficult) (this is what Jesus promises I believe...so you probably don't want to come to our church now...oh well) But let's kill the religious spirit for a moment and acknowledge the fact that God calls us to change the world. Some of us are called to do that by taking meals to the single mom up the street, some are called to start a house church and some of us are called to organize and assemble the body of Christ to Kick the living crap out of poverty, aids, and African starvation. All are important, all are in line with God's desire for us, and all are needed.

While some would argue with me, I believe there are things like transparency and depth that can only happen in a house church setting. But a single house church cannot align the resources, energy and passion of the body the way a mega church can when trying to achieve a BHAG (Big Hairy Audacious Goal).

That Said, the greatest threat to deep intimacy with Christ and each other is numeric growth in a church. A house church offers a much more conducive setting for deep, authentic intimacy to happen.

Here is my point. We need both! And I believe we need more iterations and manifestations of the body in all different shapes, sizes and colors, worship styles, artistic designs, acts of kindness, acts in general, etc...

If you are only going to a megachurch on Sundays and not participating (really participating) in a life group, house church or anything else you want to call it, then you are missing out on the deep intimacy that comes from doing life with close, real, authentic people and you are never fully known by anyone and cannot therefore ever really recieve love from anyone because you don't know if they love the real you, because all they know and are able to love is the fake you. HMMMM? What did I just say???

If you are only in a house church, you run the risk of calling the BHAG irrelevant. I believe God assembles the body in different ways for different seasons for different purposes as He wages war on a very real enemy. A single house church can''t effectively make a difference in a war torn region. A network of housechurches could, but then there assembled and look very much like a megachurch in disguise so no one calls them a megachurch. What did that mean???

Maybe we should stop trashing the church forms and start embracing the beauty it offers in the plethora of choices we have to embrace it. Maybe we ought to create new ones with the gift of creativity that seems so prevalent in the body these days. Hey, I have an idea...What about BAR CHURCH (oh wait, that one is already taken). How about Nail Salon and Liquor store church? How about rehab church? Fishing Church? Clean the bathrooms in the Porn shop church? Weidemann church? City Hall church? Real Estate church? ATM Church? Gas Pump Church? Cheese Church? Video Night Church? Firepit church? Soccer Mom Church? Hotspot church? Airport church? Third World Country Church? Kentucky Church? Oval Office Church? Post Office Church? Taco Bell Church?

I guess we can sit back and complain and be skeptical and ultimately paralyze ourselves in a prison of cynicism(God knows we all have the right to do so) or we can step in and make a difference in a world that desperately needs Him. Maybe God shows up as people.

Maybe, God shows up as the single mom dragging her kid up the street or as a nun who just helps people die with dignity, or as a priest who lays down his life for a Jew in Auschwitz. Or maybe God shows up as a Pastor of a megachurch to fund aids medications to war torn Rwanda or maybe He shows up and starts a parachurch that feeds starving kids around the world, or maybe He shows up as you or me.

Maybe, we don't go to church at all. Maybe we are the church. Hmmmmmm, I think this blog comment might just be a word for me personally! Maybe!!!

Love Wins....\o/ T

Anonymous said...

As a pastor, and therefore church leader, (by position and hopefully by influence) I am constantly fighting the balance between teaching people about freedom and the fact truth that if you love God, there are certain things that should characterize your life. Giving to the church is one of them. Where I get into trouble is I believe that for some people that will be 10% for others it will be 5% and yet for some it may well be 50%. The trick is for us to pray and LISTEN to God. I have had a staff person resign over this issue because he felt that Scripture clearly taught 10% and I was being too vague by allowing to people to operate on their own individual sole liberty. We're about to move to boxes at the doors much like the ancients did at the temple and offereings at our house church small groups, much like the early church did. I imagine I'll get in some trouble for that as well. But I'm ok with that, in fact I've made my peace with getting in trouble with people. IF I'm getting in trouble for something I believe God has told me to do. I agree with you that there are many problems in the church, and that you have correctly identified many (while leaving many others out). The interesting thing to me is that church is made up of broken people. People who fail, who sin, who are not doing the things they want to be doing, and who are doing the things they dont' want to be doing. They're are many churches that make my stomach curdle like day old mild sitting in my car, in the hot Ohio sun. I collect pictures of stupid church signs and almost wrecked my car the other day running down a van to get a picture of an assonine bumper sticker. I personally was abused as a child by a "church leader." I was used as the personal scapegoat for the pastors son until one day they tried to pin something on me and I was having surgery at the time of the offense. I had the misfortune of going to a Bible college where I didn't fit in because I asked too many questions. I was fired from a "ministry" position because the pastors daughter got caught having sex with her boyfriend in church and I told him he was wrong for covering it up. That is actually a very abbreviated list of stupid moronic things that have happened to me, but I wanted to establish that I am well aware of all the shortcomings of the church. I do not suffer from inverted cranial rectum syndrome, I often say I have a love/hate relationship with the church. But what blows my mind, is God set this animal up. He's the one who started it and he's the one who is preparing it for Him. Even with all of its' faults there are times when the beauty of his bride shines through. The last 12 months of my life are a tremendous testimony to that. Stories that I don't have time to get into here (I fear I've already taken up too much space). What makes the church so compelling to me is that despite all the shit that is in it (leadership and congregation together) it can still be a turly beautiful thing. One story I have to share. I have three daughters. Two years ago when my oldest was 1 she was diagnosed with a disease they told us could and probably would kill her. People started praying. People I don't even know prayed. Probably close to 1000 people that I can think of prayed. God healed her. I know he did, but his bride, his body came together and functioned the way He set it up. It was Awesome. I've been given money for food when we didn't have any of either because someone listened to God.
I guess I could sum my entire post up with this. While it will probably be debated for the rest of life on earth as we know it HOW church should operate, it can never be debated that it should operate and be operated by weak, sinners who have been touched by the inescaple riches of God's glory. Somehow, for reasons unknown to me that is how He decided to set up. Sinners and all.

Anonymous said...

Thanks Mark Clinton hopefully my 2 week degree will help me write more run on and incomplete sentences that would be really 100% verifiably sweet.

Justin said...

HA!

I just feel so stupid for spending four years getting that B.A....when I could have just picked up my Ph.D. in two weeks! Damnit!

Oh well...it's cool. I've got to run, Stacy and I are going to pick up a baby we ordered from Mark Clinton that only took six days to gestate.

Peace,
Justin

Anonymous said...

E-mail me dude - I have lost your email address and need to connect with you and you seem to have losty the use of your iChat!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Wonderful and informative web site.I used information from that site its great.
»

Anonymous said...

You have an outstanding good and well structured site. I enjoyed browsing through it Hygena single ovens Call center manager goldthorn park erectile dysfunction online timeshare buy hot naked milfs Percocet neurontin side effects How many erections on a dose of levitra Robin williams graphic design business card